Finding a pizza place to eat in West Chester is not too difficult. After all, there are over 70 in and around West Chester. However, each has its own story and own feeling. Matt and I planned on meeting around the time the shop opened so we could get the freshest test possible. It was a brisk morning (as usual lately) with snow still on the ground. We decided for our first review to be West Chester Pizza Cafe. A perfect place for commuters like Matt or someone who lives here, like me, as it was within walking distance of the town.
The West Chester Community
It is hard to capture the true vibe of a place so early when it opens instead of during peak hours. But even at 12:30 on a Tuesday, there were people coming in and out. We headed inside to order. After we ordered, we asked for permission to film and explained that we belonged with WCUPA Life Magazine. Before we even had our pizzas, they were more than happy to tell us how they support local West Chester businesses. They have an entire 3 bulletin boards filled with local businesses to support them. Which is the beauty of living in a town like this.
While heading back outside to try the pizza, before we even opened the box, someone approached us and asked what we were doing. We explained that we were filming a review, and he decided to give us some of his own two cents. After talking about living in New York, he mentioned it was impossible to find a pizza place in the state that makes them on par. But he left a raving review by saying, “That’s the best sauce in the state, hands down!”
The Pizza…
After opening the box, I can see instantly that he was not lying. The slice was so vibrant. The colors had taste you could see. A deep red for the tomato sauce and beautifully placed parmesan cheese sprinkled on top. The crust looked crispy and golden, exactly the way pizza should look. When we took our first bite, it was clear why that guy felt so strongly about it. The sauce had a real depth to it, not just tomato paste thrown on a slice. You could taste the care that went into making it. After nearly scarfing down the entire slice, it was finally time for the ratings. Matt gave it an 8.2/10, noting that the only thing he did not like so much was the floppiness of the pizza. But I personally love a floppy slice and gave it an 8.6/10.
Overall…
We spent some time standing outside in the cold, talking about what we were tasting and getting some footage for the video. Other people were coming and going, grabbing slices just like we were doing. It was clear that West Chester Pizza Cafe has built something special here in West Chester. It’s not just a pizza place. It’s a spot where people come because they know the quality is going to be there.
If you’re in West Chester and haven’t tried West Chester Pizza Cafe yet, it’s worth the trip. Whether you live here or you’re just visiting, grab a slice and taste why that guy couldn’t stop raving about the sauce. It really is that good.
You can find West Chester Pizza Cafe at 701 W Nields St, West Chester, PA 19382. Or call them at (610)-429-8282.
